YOU ARE HERE:>>REAL or FAKE >>Fake Roman brooches 3

 

28th January 2006

From the same seller as several other fakes, these two...at the same time!!

 






 

 From Ramon

9th November 06

More  Lions

http://tinyurl.com/yj8h9q 110049395784
http://tinyurl.com/y5luxn 260044899457
http://tinyurl.com/saeaz 230047764909

 

 





UPDATE 2020.

Oh dear!!!

This is very disappointing.

 

 

 





 

Credit: from PAS (the Portable Antiquities Scheme  run by the British Museum and Amgueddfa Cymru - National Museum Wales )

This entry is here.

Found (in London) in water?????

Hmmmm.

Looks more like something made in Eastern Europe quite recently!

 



Two of these were sold on eBay by notorious sellers of fakes.

Compare......

 

 



What's going on here? 

And this is not the only modern fake reported to the PAS as found by a detectorist and then published on their website.  I'm not criticising the folk at PAS as they can't be experts about everything  but it raises the question:  have people actually found such forgeries as they report to the PAS or is this some type of scam. Get a fake "authenticated" and then sell it with this reasurring opinion???

 

 

4th March 2006

Remember the galley brooches from page one?

Advertised as  being rare.

Yet more from the same sellers.

And yet  another lion....

 

 

 

 

 






And coincidently the lion and galley fakes turn up together again

 

 




 

From Ramon

4th April 2006

A new type of galley.

http://tinyurl.com/qowpy     7398160331

http://tinyurl.com/paj2k     6619684225

 

 

 

 





 

   From rialtos

10th March 2006

 

And yet another!

One would think that inexperienced  buyers would  notice how many identical pieces were on eBay!

 

This seller often makes his pics very dark.

The close up is the pic lightened and with reduced gamma.

Then you can see the qualityof the surface.

 

In case you have not noticed, there are many further examples of this fake on this page.

 

 




 

    From rialtos 

26th April 06

Say, now HERE's a handsome piece. Haven't seen anything like it. This week, that is.

 

http://tinyurl.com/nek6j

 

 




 

6th July 06

Another from the same seller.

One would have thought that a sufficient number had appeared on eBay for potential buyers to have become suspicious.

 

 




26th August 06

Here are a few more of this sub-type fake from the same group of eBay sellers.





 

But look what I have found.

A genuine example!

But they are rare and they are small.

Only 22mm.

See here for this rare type of Roman boat brooch

 

 




26th August 06

Before finally closing this particular issue, something to cause consternation.

This offered at $1200 by an entirely reliable dealer.

 



And more recently, in 2014.



.

 

March 2011.

These rather seemed to disappear from the market for a few years but are now once again appearing. And another supposedly silver one (see the other on page 1 of this section) which looks wonderfully new.

 



.

By  the middle of 2011 these were back in supply, on eBay,  the exact same fakes, but now appearing as "replicas" or "reproductions".

 A lot of new collectors have been stung!

 




.

The same factory in the Balkans which made the fakes previously  widely sold are now making  these as well, but no longer trying to ass them off as genuine.

 





Next page about>> forgeries of Roman brooches

2020

More and more and more








The last one above sold honestly as a reproduction: or better put, a new invention.

 

 




 

 

A new variant of the fake galley brooch.>>>>